Her Need for Planning is Driving Me Crazy!!
What’s the plan?
I remember getting that question a LOT during my 28 yr. marriage. It seems a “plan” was required for nearly everything. Even moving furniture together required “a plan”.
She would ask, “When two guys move heavy stuff, they don’t even talk. How do you get anything done??” My smug answer was always, “With upper body strength we can overcome the need to speak to each other. Besides, by noon we’ve run out of words for the day.”
Hrumph! (I think that’s how she would spell that)
It’s taken me a ridiculously long time to get a clue as to why she always wanted “a plan” and why it was always so important to my now ex-wife. Since I started my intense study into myself, male/female relationships, and divorce… at least a plausible explanation has emerged.
Warning: If you buy into the explanation, you may also have to buy into taking some action you weren’t planning.
The planner vs. non-planner marriage is something I see a lot of in the guys I coach. Typically, it is the wife with the planning gene and the husband with the “why can’t you just relax?” gene.
When we discuss the ranking of their 6 basic emotional needs (a la Tony Robbins) compared to their wives, there is often an inversion! For example:
Him:
- Growth
- Variety
- Contribution
- Significance
- Love/Connection
- Certainty/Safety
Her:
- Certainty/Safety
- Love/Connection
- Significance
- Variety
- Contribution
- Growth
Personal rankings vary and they don’t mean the ones at the bottom are not important. Certain needs must be balanced with others and a person’s ranking of how well their needs are being met can change drastically over a lifetime. Check out this page for a clear explanation of these 6 basic needs and how they relate to each other and how they are displayed by many people. (http://www.ronitbaras.com/emotional-intelligence/personal-development-c/six-human-needs-certainty/#.UdTsz5w4iUZ)
The trend I see is that many wives have a much higher need for feelings of certainty/safety in their lives than their husbands do. (Yes, sometimes this is a display of excess control, but not always.)
Other articles you may find helpful:
Valentine’s Day When Your Wife Wants Space What Do You Do?The Secret to Getting Her to Give You What You Want
Husbands tend to rank their need for feelings of growth and significance much higher than their wives do. (Yes, sometimes this is a display of selfish “workaholism”, but not always.)
We work on what each partner can and should be doing to help support and “fill the cup” of the other….and HOW to do that.
For example, being “in on the plan” is one way you can “fill her cup”. How does she try to fill yours? Have you explained what that cup is for you?
The wives I’m familiar with like to know what is on the list, the social plans for the weekend, what food must be purchased, what the kids will eat, and whether or not there will be enough coffee creamer for tomorrow morning. They cannot understand why these things are not even on his radar and sometimes judge him harshly because of it. They show little respect for his need for relaxation and introspection (variety/growth). On a personal note, I’m also one of those guys who just doesn’t care about those things and can live with the consequences of not planning them. I’d rather use my mind on other stuff.
She, on the other hand, is judged harshly for being a control freak and a busy body. He shows little respect for her needs for predictability and organization (safety/certainty). On a personal note, I’ve been very guilty of making those accusations…and worse. ;^(
Choosing to generate feelings of love and connection in each other can get difficult when each person feels like their other highly ranked emotional needs are unimportant in the eyes of their partner. This is when most fights start. And the worst part of that is that neither can verbalize the root cause of the bad feelings. The “cause” of the fight morphs into something totally unrelated.
If she has ranked a need of hers as an 8 out of 10 and told him this, then he gets to choose whether or not he wants to demonstrate to her that it matters to him. I believe that the love/connection feelings will suffer in a relationship each time a partner willingly shows that the needs of the other are not important.
Q: Why does my wife always want a plan for everything we do?
A: Because for her, planning isn’t controlling—it’s certainty and safety. Her emotional system feels calmer when she can predict the day, the weekend, or the next step. When you dismiss planning, she feels dismissed. When you include her in the plan, you fill her cup in ways you may not realize.
Q: What can I do when I’m a “relax and go with the flow” guy and she needs structure?
A: You don’t need to change your personality—you just need to honor her top emotional need. If her highest need is certainty and yours is variety or growth, the goal isn’t to match her but to show you understand what stabilizes her. A little structure from you creates a lot of peace for her.
Q: How do our different emotional needs create so much conflict in the relationship?
A: Because most couples don’t realize they are operating from inverted emotional priorities. She leads with safety. You lead with growth or significance. When each partner feels their top needs aren’t respected, love and connection crumble. Fights start over coffee creamer but are actually about unmet emotional needs.
Q: How do I “fill her cup” without losing myself or feeling controlled?
A: You fill her cup by showing her that her needs matter—not by surrendering yours. When you demonstrate that certainty, organization, and predictability are important because they matter to her, she feels loved. When she sees you doing this freely, she becomes far more open to supporting your need for freedom, growth, and relaxation.
Q: Why do small disagreements blow up into big arguments?
A: Because the fight isn’t about chores or schedules—it’s about unspoken emotional needs. When her need for certainty feels dismissed or your need for growth feels ignored, resentment builds. The argument morphs into something unrelated because neither person knows how to name the real issue: “My need doesn’t feel important to you.”
Q: What’s the plan for fixing this planner vs. non-planner dynamic?
A: Step one: Understand and respect each other’s emotional needs. Step two: Choose intentional actions that fill each other’s cup—include her in the plan, and let her see where you need freedom. Step three: Lead with love/connection first. When a man willingly shows he values her needs, the whole relationship softens and strengthens.
Author 
Have questions about your relationship?
Apply for a free, no strings, 90 minute deep dive personalized coaching session to help you identify what to focus on and what to avoid to get you moving toward the future you want. We offer a unique form of Men’s Coaching and we attract smart guys who see through surface level hype and bravado. We hide nothing and hold nothing back. We know that everything you want is behind your fear and skepticism…just like it was for us.
